TenantMagic

Learn more about TenantMagic's tenant screening services with our complete review. Includes info on TenantMagic, pricing, competitor comparisons, and FAQs.

Updated on December 15th, 2022

The SMB Guide is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

TenantMagic is a tenant screening service that provides online rental applications and comprehensive tenant screening reports to property managers, owners, and agents. Reports include credit, criminal, and eviction reporting, as well as credit score checks. TenantMagic provides screening of residential tenants and commercial lease guarantors.

Also Consider

MyRental

Rental screening in minutes, not days. Find out what you don't know.

Screen Today

4.5 billion records spanning 50+ years.

1,000,000+ users nationwide.

3,100+ counties covered.

Pricing:

Plan

Pricing

Residential screening

$37.50 /screening.

Commercial lease guarantor

$40.00 /property.

Review:

TenantMagic is an easy-to-use tenant screening service that offers detailed reports and simple application processes for applicants. With quick results that include standard screening checks, landlords and property managers gain access to three comprehensive reports that cover credit, criminal, and evictions history.

Pros:

  • The platform's criminal background check includes violent offender and sex offender searches.
  • TenantMagic promises instant results to help automate processes.
  • Landlords, agents, and property managers can use the service for free as the applicant is required to pay.
  • TenantMagic integrates with PropertyZar, a complete property management software that costs $25.00 per month.
  • Landlords and property managers gain access to legal forms through TenantMagic's partnership with US Legal Forms.
  • The company offers a mobile app that's available on iOS and Android devices.
  • TenantMagic's forms are available in Spanish.

Cons:

  • TenantMagic is unable to provide instant criminal check results for Wyoming, Delaware, South Dakota, and Massachusetts.
  • Compared to top competitors Zumper and Tenant Tracks, TenantMagic is the more costly option.
  • The platform's reports are missing previous address history, employee and income verification, and terrorist alerts.

Reputation:

TenantMagic has a very limited number of reviews available online. However, we did find two customer reviews on Facebook that average 5 out of 5 stars. While one reviewer praised the excellent customer service and ease of use, another reviewer stated that there was a slight learning curve when they initially started using the service.

At-a-Glance:

Feature

TenantMagic

Price

$37.50 /screening.

Eviction history

Credit report

Nationwide criminal check

Renter pay option

Mobile app

Customer support

Telephone, email.

TenantMagic vs Zumper Comparison.
TenantMagic vs. Zumper:

TenantMagic and Zumper both provide a single package with identical services, such as standard credit, eviction, and criminal background checks. TenantMagic, although performing similar screening procedures, is the more costly option, charging customers at least $7.50 more than Zumper.

TenantMagic vs. Zumper Comparison:

Offer

TenantMagic

Zumper

Price

$37.50 /screening.

$30.00 /screening.

Eviction history

Credit report

Nationwide criminal check

Renter pay option

x

Mobile app

Online application

TenantMagic vs Tenant Tracks Comparison.
TenantMagic vs. Tenant Tracks:

Tenant Tracks is $11.50 more affordable than TenantMagic and offers the best value for money as its plan includes screening checks missing from TenantMagic's plan. These include previous address history, terrorist alerts, and identity fraud checks. However, unlike Tenant Tracks, TenantMagic offers a comprehensive mobile app.

TenantMagic vs. Tenant Tracks Comparison:

Offer

TenantMagic

Tenant Tracks

Price

$37.50 /screening.

From $25.99 /screening.

Eviction history

Credit report

Nationwide criminal check

Previous address history

x

Terrorist alert

x

Identity fraud

x

Mobile app

x

TenantMagic vs TurboTenant Comparison.
TenantMagic vs. TurboTenant:

The most noticeable difference between TenantMagic and TurboTenant is the price. While the two competitors offer identical screening checks, TurboTenant is $7.50 more costly than TenantMagic. For the low-cost option, TenantMagic does offer a complete mobile app. However, unlike TenantMagic, TurboTenant does offer debt payment history.

TenantMagic vs. TurboTenant Comparison:

Offer

TenantMagic

TurboTenant

Price

$37.50 /screening.

$45.00 /screening.

Eviction history

Credit report

Nationwide criminal checks

Debt payment history

x

Online application

Mobile app

x

Renter pay option

Key Information:

Legal Name

TenantMagic LLC

Founder

Jay Apple

Founding Date

Jan 01, 2010

Address

675 Alpha Dr., Highland Heights, Ohio 44143

Number of Employees

2

Number of Customers

99

Email

info@tenantmagic.net

Telephone

1 (877) 462-0960

Website

https://www.tenantmagic.net/

FAQs:

What is TenantMagic's price range?

TenantMagic is free for property managers, landlords, and real estate agents. Applicants pay for the screenings, with pricing starting at $37.50 per screening report.

Does TenantMagic offer a free trial?

No. However, TenantMagic is free for landlords, homeowners, and property managers. Potential applicants are responsible for paying the screening fee.